Emily of New Moon, L.M. Montgomery (1923)

Or Know your Apple, Know your Century!


I recently reread Emily of New Moon, the first book of three in a series by Anne of Green Gables author L. M. Montgomery and frankly, except for the first Anne book, I like the Emily series better. Emily is very different from Anne in personality type and her series has more magical elements to it. And though like Anne, Emily is also orphaned at a young age, her home life is far from cheerful and she struggles against the oppression of a stern old aunt who not only makes her life difficult, but thwarts her love of writing every chance she gets. But like Anne, she has an indomitable spirit that gets her through the cruel times.

As I read Emily of  New Moon I was struck, as I often am when reading classic literature, about something historical or in this case, gastronomical, that I wanted to know more about; it had to do with apples and in all my years, I had never heard of apples described like this.

For example, when a character bites into an apple, that is usually all the writer says about it, or sometimes with a short description, “Mike bit into a juicy red apple.” And because readers know what a juicy red apple tastes and looks like, we don’t pay it much mind and move on with the character. But if that story takes place in early 20th century Canada or America that apple may not be red, delicious or juicy. Fruit historians call this time period the golden age of apples and the variety was vast.

… in the 19th century, apples came in all shapes, sizes and guises, some with rough, sandpapery skin, others as misshapen as potatoes, ranging from the size of a cherry to bigger than a grapefruit. Colors ran the entire spectrum with a wonderful impressionistic array of patterning—flushes, stripes, splashes, and dots. There was an apple for every community, taste, purpose, and season, with winter varieties especially prized.[i]



Stanley Sloane, Still Life of Dessert Apples

  Emily of New Moon takes place in the early years of the 20th century on Prince Edward Island (PEI), Canada. New Moon is known for its apples and Emily is standing in the workroom of her neighbor surveying the long row of apples he kept on a beam for Emily and her friends to eat:

Three varieties of Lofty John’s apples were their especial favourites—the “scabby apples,” that looked as if they had leprosy but were of unsurpassed deliciousness under their queer blotched skins; the “little red apples,” scarcely bigger than a crab, deep crimson all over and glossy as satin, that had such a sweet, nutty flavour; and the big green “sweet apples” that children usually thought the best of all. Emily considered that day wasted whose low descending sun had not beheld her munching one of Lofty John’s big green sweets. [ii]

How odd it would sound if we read, “Mike bites into a scabby, leprous-looking apple of wonderful deliciousness.”  But it would be true!



[i] Tim Hensley, A Curious Tale: The Apple in North America

[ii] LM Montgomery, Emily of New Moon, (New York: Bantam), 32. First published in 1923 by Frederick A. Stokes Co.

14 thoughts on “Emily of New Moon, L.M. Montgomery (1923)

  1. Hello there! What a wonderful review. I too have been reading this book again thought of finding anything written about it on WP and came across your post!

    And i too like Emily series better than rest of Anne series. Because it is more realistic and spicy.

    And while I was reading the variety of apple part I wondered where would I find them all. And that I should be more attentive to apple we get here. But both because of I live in a warm climate and because all those varieties are lost i’ll have to be contented with the hybrid ones. But thank you once again for finding out these interesting information. That too with references! 👍🏽


  2. Wonderful review. Countless varieties of apples are lost forever. We had a very old apple tree that died when I was twelve. No one knew the name, and I have never seen a similar apple fruit ever again.


  3. Wow, this is so interesting — I knew that “heirloom” tomatoes are a thing, but it didn’t occur to me that the same loss of variety would apply to other produce as well… ~~the more you know~~


    • Good point about heirloom tomatoes. And I remember when I first saw them-eww! It took me years to buy and try one. And they look so, well, not “like tomatoes” lol

      Yeah, and the more I know, the more I want to try a scabby apple 🙂


  4. What a fantastic review. I loved your very serious digression on apples. Lately I’ve been dipping into a blog called adamapples.blogspot.com
    His reviews remind me a bit of wine reviews, but they are much more loveable.

    Thank you for another wonderful review.


Let me know what you think!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.